4.15 ★
Fishers Retreat
House·20 guests·6 bedrooms·4 bathrooms
Fishers Retreat requires a minimum stay of 6 months, For those seeking a shorter duration, we can readily recommend similar homes in the area. And be sure to ask about the exclusive Friends of Serena VIP privileges offering additional perks to elevate your stay. Welcome to your ultimate family geta...
Amenities
Free WiFi
Pets allowed
Kitchen
Air conditioning
Washing Machine
Suitable for children
Available days
Reviews
4.15 (12)·John Frost·May 2026
We expected a much higher quality home for the price. There were stains on the couch, the refrigerator had mold, three patio chairs were torn, two kitchen stools were missing support cross beams. There were other issues and I have pictures if someone asks to see them. The house just looked like it wasn’t being maintained. I will give the homeowner contact high marks for being very responsive in acknowledging and addressing issues timely (ie. the A/C wasn’t working).
·Patrick Madden·December 2025
Booking, arrival and departure were all easy and uneventful. We were able to fit 6 families with convent kitchen, dining and lounging areas for everyone.
·Brittany·November 2025
National Convention Stay
We traveled from Tennessee with a group of high school kids for a national convention. Overall, we had a great stay. The home was clean and there was plenty of space for us. Very minor improvements could be adding TVs in all the bedrooms and making sure there are full rolls of toilet paper on the toilet paper roller in the bathroom and a full roll of paper towels upon the stay. Just small things and not enough to deduct stars. The owner was very responsive and helpful during the duration of our trip. All the neighbors were kind, with the exception of one across the street. Again, no fault to the owner or enough to deduct stars. You can't choose your neiighbors, unfortunately!
·Doug·September 2025
HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE / HOUSE
This was by far the worst experience I've ever had with a owner or through a service. They constantly harrass you trying to upcharge for every nickel / dime. The furnitures were broken / they try to charge you in excess. Constantly reaching out / overbooking along with the owner reaching out to pick up a bike. Very unprofessional and will be filing a suit.
·Julie Companey·August 2025
Great Location for our Family getaway
This corner of Indy is close to a lot. The Geist waterpark access is literally across the street. Terrific playground, beach with lifeguards. We spent a full day at the Children's museum - an amazing place for all ages. The house had so many beds that we had options to decide where everyone would sleep (6 adults, 4 kids under age 6). We did find one bedroom on the 2nd floor to be absolutely unbearably hot. We couldn't find any vents in the room. The only portable fan provided was broken. The availability of cribs, and a highchair, was awesome. Yes, the master bedroom has a king, a queen and two twins. It's an interesting layout. Having multiple bathrooms for 3 families was awesome too.The kitchen has dated and mismatched dishware and cooking ware but we managed. We found the oven to not heat accurately for items we were baking or cooking, not sure if the temp is accurate? The grill in back was dirty but worked well. The best part of the house for our crew? The room FULL of toys. The kids had endless fun exploring what was in there and the pop a shot in the basement gave inspiration to the 6 year old to try out basketball when home. Thank you!
Good to know
House Rules
Check-in: 4 pm
Check-out: 11 am
Pets: allowed
Smoking inside: not allowed
Cancellation policy
100% refund up to 30 days before arrival
50% refund up to 14 days before arrival